Sadly, I can't title this one WUBRG Wargs!
I went to a Hobbit prerelease last night at my FLGS Intergalactic Plastic. Here's what I opened:
I really struggled with deckbuilding here. It's harder in sealed than in drafts; the card pool is much larger yet I have less fixing than I generally pull from drafts. It's harder to get all five colors to work, as you'll see here. Here's the deck I had at the end of the night, though the original version was much different:
In the first round I was matched up against an opponent at their second prerelease. Despite their newness, they had a great grasp of how good their cards were. (I would call their Mardu deck "Seek the Smaug".) I played Giant's Boulder (which is an absolutely amazing card for everything I'm trying to do) and they played Nori, Teller of Tales on turn two. I followed that up with Dáin Ironfoot and then they played The Arkenstone's adventure, Seek the Heart, to tutor up Smaug the Magnificent. I spent turn four playing Ragged Short Spear and Ravening Warg, but they dropped Smaug, hit me, and it was clear I was in trouble. I attached the spear to the Warg on the next turn and swung in with the Ferocious trigger and double strike on both my creatures. I followed that up with Goblin Plate Mail, so I wasn't out of it yet. They played Sting, Bilbo's Sword on their fifth turn to take the tide back, then Fearsome Goblin Pair, which is a great card. On my sixth turn I attacked with both creatures and probably shouldn't've. After they hit me again, I drew for my turn and scooped.
In the second game, I played Old Thrush on turn two and got jealous when they played Thror's Map. I passed and they cast Dain, Lord of the Iron Hills. Thankfully I had The Chief Warg on the next turn. They followed that up with Dwarven Shortsword. I played Azog, Moria's Ruin (who, you'll notice, is not in the final version of the deck) and sacrificed my thrush to get a goblin army and a card. My opponent played Iron Hills Stalwart. On turn six, I played Giant's Boulder, Ravening Warg, and Enchanted River's Grasp on the Stalwart. They dropped Ori, Keeper of Songs and the board was pretty well gummed up at that point. On their next turn, they Stirred Up Trouble, to kill my Ravening Warg. On turn eight, I played The Black Arrow and equipped my Chief Warg to attack and get the Ferocious bonus card. They cast Seek the Heart to go get Smaug, cast him, and attacked. Thankfully, I had another Enchanted River's Grasp, which I locked Smaug down with next turn. I also attacked with (my) Dain and played Guardian of the Halls. My opponent played Bilbo's Deadly Slice to kill (my) Dain on their turn, but on the next turn I was able to cast Thranduil, the Elvenking and keep attacking. My opponent played the Arkenstone and Sting, but Thranduil was big enough that I won.
For game three, my opponent wanted to be on the draw. I got the Ragged Short Spear out on turn two. They played their own Old Thrush. I played Ravening Warg and they cast The Mountain King's Return, another cool card, and smartly discarded Fearsome Goblin Pair to it. I played Ravenhill Flock on turn four. I play Toothy in EDH (the deck is called "Pir and Toothy go to the Library") so I know how good those draw for counters creatures are. They got their Goblin Pair the next turn and then immediately Stirred Up Trouble, sacrificing it to kill my Ravening Warg. With three mana left, they--you guessed it---Seeked the Heart to get Smaug. I played The Chief Warg on my next turn and they played The Arkenstone. (They were missing a second red source for Smaug!) I played Thranduil, Sindarin Liege and made a bad attack, losing my Chief Warg. They couldn't cast Smaug, but they did have Head of the Hunt, which is really good. Two turns later, at the beginning of turn eight, Turns were called and I cast Stone-Giant of High Pass. My opponent had never gone to turns before, so I explained it. On their turn (Turn 1) they played Thror's Map to get a mountain and summon Smaug and attack. On my next turn (Turn 2) I attacked well and then killed two creatures with the Stone-Giant's ability. I foolishly didn't take out the Head of the Hunt first and my opponent got two wolf tokens. My opponent attacked back on Turn 3 but didn't take me out. With my beefy Ravenhill Flock and the Stone-Giant, I swung in, put them at four, then sacrificed the new wall to hit them for lethal. 1-0.
In round one, my opponent had played Smaug each game. In round two, I was up against a Golgari "Fierce and Ferocious" deck, piloted by someone who often drafts with me. I went first, but they played a Nighthowl Pursuer on turn one that would wind up doing me a bunch of damage. I played Old Thursh on turn two and they played Troop of Ponies, the second 2-drop colorless card that made me jealous. They sacrificed it to ramp on turn three. On turn four I drew and played a second Old Thrush, which they outclassed on their turn with Beorn the Fierce. Thankfully I had an Enchanted River's Grasp for it on turn five. They spent turn five playing two Crude Bent Blades that killed both of my Thrushes.
On turn six I cast Gandalf, Wandering Wizard and felt pretty good. That confidence was misplaced because of a Little Bear. That stupid little bear untapped Beorn, who attacked and with the power of a Reverent Howl slapped me down to 4 life, putting them to 27. I played The Chief Warg and Ravening Warg the next turn. They attacked again, putting me to 1 life. I played Dain, Ironfoot, but on their turn they Stirred Up Trouble to limit by blockers. I had nothing to do on turn nine and they attacked to kill me, with Smaug, Wicked Wurm in hand.
In game two, Nighthowl Pursuer hit the board right away again. Then I played Old Thrush. They cast Wargling on their second turn, dispelling the deja vu, thankfully. I had Dain Ironfoot on turn three and Ravenhill Flock on turn four before they flashed in Little Bear. My opponent didn't give the ravens a chance to flock, though, and Quarreled it on their fourth turn. After attacking, they were winning 13 to 16. I played Goblin Plate Mail, and attacked but once again they played Beorn the Fierce. That triggered all the ferocity and I went to 5 life. I cast The Chief Warg, but it wasn't enough. They used Beorn's ability (which we'd missed before) and it was all over. 1-1.
That round was very quick. Thankfully my opponent was willing to play more. They beat me in a third game with the deck (Beorn again!) and then borrowed another friend's deck to whip me a fourth time. After that I made a bunch of changes to my deck to get the version pictured above. In particular, they told me about the Thrandul, the Elvenking combo with Guardian of the Halls and Woodland Weavemaster, so I added the Weavemaster to the deck. I had been having trouble figuring out what to keep in for White (my plans with equipment and dwarves hadn't really panned out) but my friend advised that I put An Unexpected Party in, which was a good call: even if I didn't get the second white source, the adventure was worth it.
In round three, I was up against another skilled opponent that is a regular at Intergalactic Plastic, who was running a strong Mardu deck. (This round was quite intense and my notes are sparse due to my concentration on the game, sorry!) I again had Old Thrush on turn two. The next play was on their turn four with Dwarven Provisioner. I cast Thranduil, the Elvenking on turn five, but they had a Bilbo's Deadly Slice for it. I recovered the next turn with Gandalf, Wandering Wizard. They played Gollum, Silent Slinker and a Ravening Warg. I played Guardian of the Halls, which they outclassed with Esgaroth Garrison. The game dragged on, but I got out a second Elvenking and won with it.
In game two, I got hit early. I went to 1 life against their 18, but I held on. I got the Elvenking combo with both elves so I could pump it up. Many times my opponent made a play that seemed like it would spell my demise, but I got around it on my turn. I must have been at 1 for over five turns before I started to turn the game around and at least ten turns before I won. (I think I won with the Stone-Giant this time.) This was pretty criminal. The probability I was going to win that game was vanishingly small and didn't tip to my side until the very end. I got very lucky. 2-1.
2-1 is respectable, but that could have easily been 0-3. I squeaked out round one, got mauled in round two, and then won round three on the smallest of life margins. I-... oh, it's not time for the post-mortem yet because my friend wants to play a third game with me!
In bonus round four, I was up against the player who had helped me fix my deck up after round two. They were running Simic, which I assumed meant Elves, but instead it was just lots of card draw. They won in three games, and had multiple copies of good cards like Old Fat Spider Can't See Me, Bilbo Baggins, Burglar, and Lakeshore Apothecary. I did not take notes and I'm not even sure how I won a game. (They frequently read these posts, so maybe they'll chime in in the hard-to-use comments.)
This was officially a 2-1, kinda a 2-2, and something that was very close to a 0-4. I really don't trust my sealed deckbuilding skills. I hope I get some good comments about how I should have built my deck differently. The one thing I realize is that I definitely should have run my Mirkwood Nurturers. They would have worked great with many of the cards in my deck, including the Old Thrushes and the Ragged Short Spear. With them it might have even been worthwhile to put the Crude Bent Blades in too!
No matter what, I had a really great time. Happy Hobbit Magicking to you!

































